An Employer's Prompt Remedial Action Results in a Fifth Circuit Reversal of a Race Harassment Jury Verdict

-
On January 31, 2014, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a hostile work environment jury verdict based on race, finding that the employer's prompt remedial action was sufficient to defeat the claim.  See Williams-Boldware v. Denton County, Texas, No. 13-40044.

In that case, the African-American plaintiff complained about racially inappropriate language directed at her by her Caucasian male co-worker.  Within twenty-four hours of her complaint, the co-worker had issued a written apology, and the complaining employee's immediate supervisor reported the incident to human resources.  The employer then reprimanded the co-worker, required him to participate in diversity training, and transferred the plaintiff to a different division to ensure she had no contact with the co-worker.  

The race harassment claim proceeded to trial, and the trial court denied the employer's motion for judgment as a matter of law.  The jury awarded the plaintiff over $400,000 in mental anguish damages and the employer appealed.

Reversing the trial court's denial of judgment as a matter of law, the Fifth Circuit focused on the employer's post-complaint conduct, which included:

  • the supervisor's prompt report of the complaint to human resources.
  • the employer's meeting with the plaintiff to discuss her complaint.
  • the employer's acquiescence to the plaintiff's request to personally confront the co-worker.
  • the employer's request for the plaintiff's input on an appropriate response.
  • the employer's verbal reprimand of the co-worker.
  • the employer's requirement that the co-worker attend diversity training.
In short, the employer's remedial efforts were prompt and "effectively halted"the racially harassing conduct entitling it to judgment as a matter of law.




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

(Un)Intended Consequences? Can Employers be Sued Under the New Texas Heartbeat Act?

-
On September 1, 2021, the most restrictive abortion law in the country went into effect in Texas.  Known as the "Texas Heartbeat Act," the statute, which creates a new subchapter of Chapter 171 of the Texas Health and Safety Code, privatizes a right of action against people who aid and abet abortions in violation of the new law. More specifically, the statute provides that "any person" other than a state actor can bring an action against "any person" who: knowingly engages in [or intends to engage in] conduct that aids or abets the performance or   inducement of an abortion , including paying for or reimbursing the costs of an abortion through insurance or otherwise, if the abortion is performed or induced in violation of this subchapter, regardless of whether the person knew or should have known that the abortion would be performed or induced in violation of this subchapter. ..(emphasis added). How could this affect employers?   First, how broadly will c
Read more

Ten Things Texas Employers Need to Know About the New "No Need for a Firearm Carry Permit" Law

-
 At a time when gun violence is increasing across the country, and based on publicly available data, Texas currently ranks second in the nation (behind Illinois) in mass shootings for 2021, the Texas Legislature enacted the Firearm Carry Act of 2021.  Here's what Texas employers need to know: 1.     The effective date of the new law is September 1, 2021. 2.     The law applies to persons 21 years of age or older and not otherwise prohibited by state or federal law from possessing a firearm, and to those 18 years or older in the military. 3.    Persons who meet the criteria in #2 above will be able to carry a firearm without a government issued license or permit, which means they will not be required to take gun safety and handling courses as a prerequisite to carrying. 4.     The law does not prohibit an employer from prohibiting an employee who lawfully carries without a permit from possessing the firearm on the employer's premises. 5.       An employer must follow the postin
Read more

Are Private Employers Ready for the New Sexual Harassment Laws in Texas?

-
Texas is considered an employer-friendly state, so it may come as quite a surprise that several bills that significantly impact sex harassment law passed, without fanfare, in the last legislative session, and go into effect today, September 1, 2021.  More specifically, the legislature amended several sections of Chapter 21 of the Texas Labor Code, which includes the state's version of Title VII, to be more in line with the laws of California.  Here's what employers need to know: First, the legislature amended Chapter 21 to provide that with respect to sexual harassment , an "employer" is a person who employs 1 or more employees or "acts directly in the interest of an employer in relation to an employee."   What does this mean and why does it matter?   Until today, Chapter 21 has applied to employers with 15 or more employees; therefore, this amendment now covers virtually every employer with respect to sex harassment claims.  It also means that individual s
Read more