An Employer's Prompt Remedial Action Results in a Fifth Circuit Reversal of a Race Harassment Jury Verdict

On January 31, 2014, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a hostile work environment jury verdict based on race, finding that the employer's prompt remedial action was sufficient to defeat the claim.  See Williams-Boldware v. Denton County, Texas, No. 13-40044.

In that case, the African-American plaintiff complained about racially inappropriate language directed at her by her Caucasian male co-worker.  Within twenty-four hours of her complaint, the co-worker had issued a written apology, and the complaining employee's immediate supervisor reported the incident to human resources.  The employer then reprimanded the co-worker, required him to participate in diversity training, and transferred the plaintiff to a different division to ensure she had no contact with the co-worker.  

The race harassment claim proceeded to trial, and the trial court denied the employer's motion for judgment as a matter of law.  The jury awarded the plaintiff over $400,000 in mental anguish damages and the employer appealed.

Reversing the trial court's denial of judgment as a matter of law, the Fifth Circuit focused on the employer's post-complaint conduct, which included:

  • the supervisor's prompt report of the complaint to human resources.
  • the employer's meeting with the plaintiff to discuss her complaint.
  • the employer's acquiescence to the plaintiff's request to personally confront the co-worker.
  • the employer's request for the plaintiff's input on an appropriate response.
  • the employer's verbal reprimand of the co-worker.
  • the employer's requirement that the co-worker attend diversity training.
In short, the employer's remedial efforts were prompt and "effectively halted"the racially harassing conduct entitling it to judgment as a matter of law.




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

(Un)Intended Consequences? Can Employers be Sued Under the New Texas Heartbeat Act?

Ten Things Texas Employers Need to Know About the New "No Need for a Firearm Carry Permit" Law

Are Private Employers Ready for the New Sexual Harassment Laws in Texas?